Symphonic's Roblox deal promised artists royalties for all plays, then the line was called an error

NotNoise editorial collage: the official Symphonic and Roblox wordmarks as black xerox cutouts on a white torn strip, with a blank paper slip taped between them, on acid yellow paper.
··7 min read

Music Business Worldwide said on November 14 it had been told that Symphonic's Roblox press release contained an error and that Symphonic artists "will not receive royalties from the platform via the partnership," two days after a version of the release promised royalties for all plays.

The deal, announced November 12, brings what Symphonic called "hundreds of thousands of curated songs" into Roblox's Creator Store. It makes Symphonic another distributor serving independent artists to offer Roblox delivery, after DistroKid and Too Lost. As of November 16, none of the three describes a per-play payment for Roblox use on its public pages. DistroKid's help page says music sent through it "is not monetized at this time." Too Lost's page mentions "additional revenue" but names no mechanism or rate. The copy of Symphonic's release on its PR agency's site no longer mentions money.

Roblox said in July that rights holders would be able to share music "in exchange for revenue" starting "later this year." We could not find a launch announcement as of November 16.

NotNoise is also a music distributor and competes with Symphonic, DistroKid and Too Lost.

How the royalty line traveled

The release, datelined "November 12, 2026 (Tampa, FL)," said Symphonic's catalog would appear in the Creator Store with a 15-second preview. Jorge Brea, Symphonic's founder and CEO, said, "We are always looking for new ways to put our artists in front of listeners, so working with Roblox just makes sense."

Jessica Meehan, head of music partnerships at Roblox, said in the same release, "At the same time, we're able to provide artists an immersive platform to reach new listeners and cultivate dedicated fans."

One version of that release said more. Record of the Day posted a copy on November 13. It was still live when we checked on November 16, and it includes this sentence: "Artists will receive royalties for all plays on the Roblox platform, which will be collected by Symphonic and distributed to rightsholders per their publishing contracts."

Music Business Worldwide published its story at 09:02 UTC on November 14. The archived original ran under a headline promising "artists paid royalties for all plays." Its summary read, "According to Symphonic, artists will receive royalties for all plays of their music on Roblox."

MBW then added an update to the story: "We've now been told this press release contained an error: Symphonic artists will not receive royalties from the platform via the partnership." MBW did not say who told it. The original URL now redirects to the corrected story.

The copy of the release on Jaybird Communications' site no longer carries the royalty sentence, according to our checks of the live page and an archive on November 16. We did not find a separate correction notice from Symphonic.

The original version also got passed around. At 01:27 UTC on November 15, the X account @CrypticHollow43 posted "Symphonic says artists get royalties for all plays" and linked to MBW's original URL. It is a small account, and the post had no likes when we fetched it, but it shows how a claim like that keeps moving once it is out.

Three distributors, three ways of describing the money

Roblox lists other verified music sources as well, but Symphonic, DistroKid and Too Lost are the ones an independent artist is most likely to meet as a checkbox.

DistroKid went first. Roblox announced that integration on its developer forum on September 19, 2024, and MBW reported that DistroKid's 2024 beta opt-in form offered the music "on a gratis basis." DistroKid's help page, updated October 1, 2026, says, "Additionally, please note that music sent to Roblox through DistroKid is not monetized at this time." The page also says "you must fully own 100% of your music's publishing rights and not be registered with a Performing Rights Organization like ASCAP or BMI."

Too Lost followed in July. Roblox's July 27 announcement added "thousands of new songs by independent artists and labels." It said, "Every track in this catalog is distributed by Too Lost, so the music you add comes from verified, rights-cleared sources." The announcement did not mention payment.

Too Lost's help page, updated October 27, describes the Roblox option this way: "Make your music available for use within Roblox, giving you an opportunity to reach new audiences and generate additional revenue from your catalog." The page gives no mechanism, rate, or per-play figure.

Roblox has been "thinking about" artist money since 2024

When the DistroKid songs arrived in September 2024, the forum thread filled with questions about pay. A Roblox Music Team staffer replied on September 19: "Every artist participating in this DistroKid integration can choose whether they want their music shared with Roblox. The artists we've spoken to thus far are excited about the potential for more exposure. We're at the beginning of our music journey on Roblox, and we are thinking about the potential for monetization."

Nearly two years later, the author of the Too Lost announcement wrote on July 29, 2026: "However, later this year, we will support onboarding music rights holders to the Intellectual Property platform to share their music assets with developers in exchange for revenue." That is the most specific public statement about artist revenue we found from Roblox. The year has about six weeks left, and we could not find a launch announcement.

Roblox's contract for direct uploads shows how it handles royalties today. Under the Audio Upload License Agreement, updated November 16, the uploading creator warrants that "Roblox shall not be responsible for the payment of royalties, fees or any other compensation to any third party." The agreement names ASCAP, BMI, SESAC and SoundExchange. It grants Roblox "a perpetual, worldwide license" and states, "Roblox reserves all rights to directly monetize the Platform in any manner."

That agreement covers creators who upload audio themselves. The terms between Roblox and its distributors are not public, and nothing we found says distributor-delivered artists signed it. It is still the clearest public statement we found of where Roblox places royalty obligations, and it places them with the uploader.

What musicians asked, and what they were told

The objections started in the same September 2024 thread. "It's honestly ridiculous that a corporation like roblox is asking musicians to give their music for free," SinCityCello wrote on September 20. The next day, BronzedMocha wrote, "Artists are not getting paid for this." Mosspyre added, "Painful to see Roblox consider exposure as a fair alternative to pay."

On the distributor side, the checkbox often arrives with no context. "We can also add it to Roblox lmao. I don't know anything about it, how that even works?" Mroovek wrote on r/DistroKidHelpDesk on April 29. In December 2025, another user wrote, "Says my music is uploaded and I should find it by searching for it on the creator store but I can't find it."

Individual licensing deals are no easy way around the distributors. In an October forum thread, a developer with a license for Wintergatan's "Tornado" said a year had passed without the song being reinstated. A reply quoted Roblox as saying it is "currently unable to support ad hoc reviews for copyright licenses."

For two years, musicians asking about money have heard about exposure and future monetization. The one public sentence promising royalties for all plays lasted two days before MBW was told it was wrong, and it is still live on Record of the Day. Exposure can be a fair trade, but the page where an artist opts in should say plainly whether exposure is the whole deal.

Before you tick the Roblox box

Some releases may be worth placing in games for reach alone. Make that call with the documents in front of you.

  1. Find your distributor's Roblox wording and look for "monetized." DistroKid's page says "not monetized at this time." If a page promises revenue, as Too Lost's does, look for a mechanism or rate. If you can't find one, ask your distributor before opting in.
  2. Check the publishing and PRO conditions as your distributor states them. DistroKid requires 100% publishing ownership and no PRO registration. Whether a release meets those conditions depends on your own publishing setup, which our publishing royalties primer covers.
  3. Expect curation. DistroKid's page says, "Note that the Roblox Creator Store is curated; opting in doesn't guarantee your release will go live." On r/DistroKidHelpDesk, Rusty_Brains put it more bluntly: "As has been mentioned here a few times, submitting to Roblox is subject to their approval. If they did not approve your music, end of story."
  4. Decide release by release. Roblox's agreement for direct uploads grants a perpetual license. For more on how in-game placements work, see our guide to video game music licensing. If store lists are part of your comparison, our guide to switching distributors covers the move.

We will update this story if Symphonic, Roblox, DistroKid or Too Lost publishes a payment mechanism for Roblox plays.

Further reading: switching from DistroKid without losing streams.

RobloxSymphonicDistroKidToo Lostmusic distributionindependent artists