Michael Smith Gets 18 Months for Streaming Fraud, but No Restitution for the Artists in the Pool

A beatmaker in a lime overshirt finger-drumming on a sampler next to a turntable, in a scrapbook collage.
··8 min read

US District Judge John G. Koeltl sentenced Michael Smith to 18 months in prison on October 6, 2026, telling a Manhattan courtroom that "the victims are the artists" of his bot-streaming scheme, even as prosecutors said they were not seeking restitution for them.

Both lines come from Inner City Press, which reported from the courtroom. According to the US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York, Koeltl also ordered two years of supervised release and $8,091,843.64 in forfeiture. Smith, 54, of Cornelius, North Carolina, pleaded guilty on March 19, 2026, to one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud, which carries a maximum of five years.

The government's announcement lists the forfeiture but no restitution order. For the musicians and songwriters whose per-stream rate Smith's fake plays pushed down, that missing line is the part of the sentence that touches their money.

Less than half of what prosecutors wanted

Prosecutors said Smith ran the scheme from 2017 to 2024, using as many as 10,000 bot accounts at once to stream hundreds of thousands of AI-generated songs billions of times and collect more than $8 million in royalties. The release offers one comparison: in April 2023, Taylor Swift's entire catalog drew 9.3 million family-plan streams on YouTube Music, while Smith's bot accounts drew 80.9 million.

"By flooding music streaming platforms with automated bots in the place of consumers, and fake songs in the place of creativity, Smith robbed millions in royalty payments from genuine artists and their fans," US Attorney Jamie McDonald said in the release.

The office billed the case as the Justice Department's "First-Ever Criminally Charged Super-Intelligence Assisted Music Streaming Fraud." That wording is the government's own, and Music Business Worldwide noted that the March plea release said "artificial intelligence" instead. MBW also reported that both sides described it as the first criminal prosecution of its kind in the US.

Koeltl landed well below the government's number. Prosecutors asked for at least 46 months, against a guideline range of 46 to 57 months. The US Probation Office recommended 24, and Smith's lawyers asked for probation. The judge adopted none of those requests. "The 18-month term is less than half what prosecutors sought, and shorter than the US Probation Office's recommendation," MBW reported.

Smith addressed the court before he was sentenced. "I betrayed the music community I care so much about," he said, according to Rolling Stone, which reported that he also spoke of a "perverse business model."

Two plays a day, spread across every royalty statement

NotNoise editorial collage: the docket header of US v. Smith taped above one torn green paper pool sprinkled evenly with hundreds of tiny blank paper slips.
MBW's estimate, working from the government's letter: about two bot plays per song per day across an assumed 300,000-track catalog.

The Justice Department's release lays out the mechanism in the government's own words: "Royalty payments are made proportionately to musicians and songwriters from a pool of funds. As a result, streaming fraud diverts funds from musicians and songwriters whose songs were legitimately streamed by real consumers to those who use automation to falsely create the appearance of legitimate streaming."

Smith's own numbers show how quiet that diversion was built to be. Working from the government's sentencing letter, MBW laid out his early model: 52 cloud accounts running 20 bots each, 1,040 bot accounts in all, each playing about 636 songs a day.

That comes to roughly 661,440 streams daily, or $3,307.20 a day at an assumed half cent per stream. Spread across a catalog MBW assumed at 300,000 tracks, it works out to about two plays per song per day, roughly 805 a year across all platforms.

Prosecutors say Smith wanted it that way. In an October 4, 2018, email quoted in the government's filing, he wrote that "in order to not raise any issues with the powers that be we need a TON of content with small amounts of Streams." By June 2019 he was writing "we are at 88 million TOTAL STREAMS so far!!!", which MBW put at about $110,000 a month.

The Music Fights Fraud Alliance described where that money came from in a letter to the court, published by Digital Music News: "Every fraudulent stream perpetrated by Mr. Smith diluted the value of every legitimate stream occurring during the same accounting period." Spotify describes its pool in similar terms. A Spotify for Artists post says "bad actors continue to attempt to steal money from the royalty pool that should be delivered to honest, hardworking artists."

"Insignificant" to each artist, $8 million in total

Smith's lawyers built their case for leniency on that same arithmetic. In pre-sentence filings quoted by Billboard, they called the harm to any single artist "insignificant," wrote that "no victim suffered any real harm," and argued that each stream's effect on everyone else's share "is a drop in an ocean."

In court, his lawyer kept to that line. "There was only de minimus impact on any particular artist. There's no restitution because it cannot be calculated. But we are not saying no one was hurt," the lawyer said, according to Inner City Press.

Prosecutor Nicholas Chiuchiolo countered that small royalty checks matter and are sometimes the "only recognition" an artist gets, Rolling Stone reported. Koeltl's line about the victims put him on that side of the argument.

Listeners have argued over the same question. In a September r/indieheads thread, the top comment cast Spotify as the party the Justice Department was protecting. Another user replied: "This guy is stealing from artists, not Spotify."

Taken together, the sums are large. MBW reported that Smith received "more than USD $14 million in total from royalty-paying entities." The $8,091,843.64 forfeiture is "the loss figure agreed by both sides," according to MBW, reached by deducting estimated royalties from legitimate streams of his music and the money he paid back into royalty pools by buying the streaming accounts his bots used.

No restitution, and no word on where the forfeiture goes

NotNoise editorial collage: the xeroxed court caption of United States v. Michael Smith taped beside a blank torn ruled list on a green field.
The government sought no restitution, according to Inner City Press. No filing reviewed for this story says where the $8,091,843.64 forfeiture will go.

"We are not seeking restitution," the prosecutor told the court, according to Inner City Press. That matched MBW's reading of the government's sentencing letter days earlier. The letter "asks for forfeiture but no restitution," MBW wrote, because "with dilution spread across every rightsholder streaming that month, there is no victim list to pay back."

Federal law leaves room for that outcome. The Mandatory Victims Restitution Act normally requires restitution in fraud cases. It does not apply to property offenses when a court finds "the number of identifiable victims is so large as to make restitution impracticable," or when sorting out losses would complicate or prolong sentencing.

No public record shows Koeltl made that finding. What the record does show is narrower. The government did not ask for restitution, and the defense said it "cannot be calculated."

Forfeiture takes the proceeds of a crime away from the defendant, and unlike restitution it does not come with a list of victims attached. No filing or statement reviewed for this story says where Smith's forfeited money will go.

Federal regulations allow victims to petition for remission of forfeited property, but only where the forfeiture statute explicitly authorizes it. There is no public sign that anyone has filed such a petition in this case.

An r/indieheads user asked the obvious question the week Smith pleaded guilty: "Does anyone know where that money is going? The article doesn't say." Nearly seven months later, the court record still doesn't answer it for artists.

The scheme started with his own songs

Most coverage of Smith has led with the AI songs, but Koeltl framed the case around the streams. "It was not the use of AI which was targeted here," he said, according to Inner City Press.

Both sides also agree on how it began. "As the PSR explains, however, Mr. Smith initially used his own catalog of music and only turned to AI later," his lawyers wrote in an October 2 letter to the judge, citing the presentence report. Billboard reported the prosecution's account: "Prosecutors claimed he initially started by merely boosting the plays of his own music, then switched to mass-producing AI songs to fuel the scheme."

Buying plays for your own songs is the pitch working artists get constantly, and a fake play on your own catalog draws from the same shared pool as one on an AI track. Since Smith's scheme, Spotify has added a per-track minimum, and distributors have signed on to an IFPI anti-fraud program.

Questions the court record does not answer

No public source yet says whether any rightsholder will pursue civil recovery, whether platforms will claw back or redistribute anything, what happens to the royalties The MLC halted in March and April 2023, or whether anyone will petition for remission.

The court treated the dilution as real harm to real artists, which is more than the defense was willing to grant. The pro-rata system gave the court no easy way to act on that. By MBW's reading of the government's own letter, a fraud large enough to send a man to prison was spread too thin to produce a victim list.

The industry groups that pushed for the prosecution are already looking past it. "But the industry's fight against fraud is about more than one case," Michael Lewan, executive director of the Music Fights Fraud Alliance, said after the sentencing, according to MBW.

Further reading: music distribution that promotes every release.

streaming fraudMichael Smithroyaltiespro-ratarestitutionAI musicindependent artists